People Just Asked
שאלה: האם אפשר לשמוע ולהשתתף במנין ב770 בטלפון 770live ולענות לקדישים, ברכו, חזרת השץ, ופתיחת הארון? מענה: כמובן שאינו יכול לצאת ידי חובת תפילה במנין. אבל אפשר לענות אמן בטלפון. בוידיאו ובאינטרנט יש הפסק בזמן, ואין לענות וכאמן… שאלה: האם אפשר לשמוע ולהשתתף במנין ב770 בטלפון 770live ולענות לקדישים, ברכו, חזרת השץ, ופתיחת הארון? מענה: כמובן שאינו יכול לצאת ידי חובת תפילה במנין. אבל אפשר לענות אמן בטלפון. בוידיאו ובאינטרנט יש הפסק בזמן, ואין לענות וכאמן יתומה. #5616 Clarification: One can answer Amen, Kaddish, and Kedusha on 770live, over the phone (718-682-0770) but not via the website, due to a short delay. Article: May I answer Amen to a Brachah heard via Webcam? There was a massive Shul in Alexandria, Egypt, the Gemara relates, with a hall that held over one…Show more
המשך השאלה: עברתי דירה ולקחתי איתי את המזוזות שלי (השארתי בדירה הישנה מזונות אחרות - קצת פחות יקרות ומהודרות), אך בדקתי אותם כבר בחודש אלול. האם עלי לבודקם שוב, לפני שאקבע אותם בדירתי החדשה? תשובה: אין חובה, אבל… המשך השאלה: עברתי דירה ולקחתי איתי את המזוזות שלי (השארתי בדירה הישנה מזונות אחרות - קצת פחות יקרות ומהודרות), אך בדקתי אותם כבר בחודש אלול. האם עלי לבודקם שוב, לפני שאקבע אותם בדירתי החדשה? תשובה: אין חובה, אבל יש מקום להידור כזה. מקורות: ראה מס׳ מזוזה בסופה - "אבל הכל שוין שאם…Show more
It will likely be consumed by that yid and his non-Jewish family. Answer: Lechatchilah it would be best to give only foods and drinks that won't create problems later. However, there are opinions to rely on to give… It will likely be consumed by that yid and his non-Jewish family. Answer: Lechatchilah it would be best to give only foods and drinks that won't create problems later. However, there are opinions to rely on to give in such a case. Sources: כמה צדדי היתר נשנו כאן: שהאיסור רק מדרבנן, ולא…Show more
Question: Can a Bocher learning in Yeshiva (or a girl in seminary) in Eretz Yisroel change their ticket to go home early because of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19)? Are you obligated to change your ticket to come home earlier?… Question: Can a Bocher learning in Yeshiva (or a girl in seminary) in Eretz Yisroel change their ticket to go home early because of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19)? Are you obligated to change your ticket to come home earlier? I.e.: There is the letter from the Rebbe by the six-day war that your not allowed to change your plans to not go to Eretz Yisroel or to leave early. So is there the same problem here? The second part of the question is that maybe just the opposite, cause it says in Gemara that in a time of a…Show more
Question: This year, due to COVID: 1) Can a kriah of zachor be arranged just for women (and kids) in a shul after davening (withou a minyan and brachos)? 2) If yes, what about having there ten men present… Question: This year, due to COVID: 1) Can a kriah of zachor be arranged just for women (and kids) in a shul after davening (withou a minyan and brachos)? 2) If yes, what about having there ten men present who did not yet hear zachor in the morning - does that permit saying the brachos just for the kriah of zachor, meaning without having to lein terumah? Answers: No. ה״ז טלטול ס״ת שלא לצורך. ומעולם לא נהגו כן. וראה שו״ת מנח״י ט, סח. קנין תורה ז, נג. שרה״מ ו, קטז. 2. If for whatever reason it is…Show more
Question: Some times the Rebbe said that there is the gezeira against Mashke on Purim regarding Bochrim and sometimes the Rebbe said that there is no gezeira. What should I do? Answer: There is no doubt that… Question: Some times the Rebbe said that there is the gezeira against Mashke on Purim regarding Bochrim and sometimes the Rebbe said that there is no gezeira. What should I do? Answer: There is no doubt that the gezeira against mashke is applicable Purim too. See here. #7067Show more
Spelt matzah may be used but it is a mitzvah min hamuvchar to use wheat. The Rama records that this is the custom. One shouldn’t veer away from this custom unless necessary. Some are concerned that we don’t have… Spelt matzah may be used but it is a mitzvah min hamuvchar to use wheat. The Rama records that this is the custom. One shouldn’t veer away from this custom unless necessary. Some are concerned that we don’t have sufficient information about the leavening process of spelt and therefore it should be avoided unless absolutely required for health reasons. רמ״א תנג, א. אדה״ז שם ב. משנ״ב ב. הגהות מהרש״ם לארחות חיים ספינקא שם. שו״ת לבושי מרדכי ב, קמח. מנח״י ט, מט. חשב האפוד ג, ט. שרגה״מ ה, ח (ושם גם מש״כ אליו בעל מנח״י). #7062Show more
Question: Is it a problem to have a fleishik oven on top of a milchik oven or vice versa? Many houses have it set up that way. How about one for fleishig (or milchig) and one for parve? … Question: Is it a problem to have a fleishik oven on top of a milchik oven or vice versa? Many houses have it set up that way. How about one for fleishig (or milchig) and one for parve? Answer: It would depend on the model and type of oven: If they share vents, you cannot use one for fleishig and one for milchig (or Parve). This is because the steam from one oven goes into the second oven. If they do not share vents and the two compartments are attached with screws or wires (as it is…Show more
Yes. Some Sefardim are mehader to use Sefardi Sefer Torah and baal korei (and vice versa), but this isn’t me’akev, it not something that is necessary. ראה שו״ת הרא״ש ג, יא. קרית ספר להמאירי ב. מאירי שבת… Yes. Some Sefardim are mehader to use Sefardi Sefer Torah and baal korei (and vice versa), but this isn’t me’akev, it not something that is necessary. ראה שו״ת הרא״ש ג, יא. קרית ספר להמאירי ב. מאירי שבת קג, א. ב״י יו״ד סוסי׳ ערה. אהלי יעקב למהריק״ש קיג. מהר״ם גאלאנטי קכד. חכ״צ צט. נוב״י קמא יו״ד פ. תנינא יו״ד קעא. צ״צ יו״ד רח. קנאת סופרים קכא. עין יצחק יו״ד כח, טו. מהרש״ם ז, קיב. יחו״ד ב, ג. ולגבי ההברה - ראה שערי הלכה ומנהג א׳ ע׳ קיט ואילך. ובעניננו - ראה שו״ת בנין שלמה נד. יבי״א ו, יא.…Show more
Also, can they directly pass items purchased for each other? Answer: It’s permitted to pass items to each other, if not done with the intention of gazing at her beauty. Generally, it’s permitted to give each other gifts,… Also, can they directly pass items purchased for each other? Answer: It’s permitted to pass items to each other, if not done with the intention of gazing at her beauty. Generally, it’s permitted to give each other gifts, with the exception of משלוח מנות where the חתן should send to the כלה family, or the חתן family sends to the כלה. Many are particular about all gifts not to give directly to each other or ensure there are no kosher witnesses present at the time. Alternatively, one can specify clearly this is purely done for the purpose of…Show more
Check out our Purim Q&As A Freilechen Purim!
The Rebbe tells us to start living Moshiach. Is this something that I'm allowed to start living Moshiach with? I asked my Mashpia and he told me that I should ask the Rov. Answer: Absolutely unacceptable. Sources: ראה שו״ת הרמ״ע מפאנו קז: שבקושי התירו להניחן וכו׳…
If this is the sole purpose of the WhatsApp group, obviously it is absolutely forbidden. Even if the WhatsApp group contains other “kosher” entertainment, and one has the practical ability to skip over all the forbidden sections (which needs… If this is the sole purpose of the WhatsApp group, obviously it is absolutely forbidden. Even if the WhatsApp group contains other “kosher” entertainment, and one has the practical ability to skip over all the forbidden sections (which needs to be properly determined if this is at all practically possible), one may not rely on one’s temerity that they will avoid reading or viewing the un-kosher sections, unless this is their only necessary outlet for such “kosher” entertainment. As a general principle: Wherever one has a choice to avoid situations where they might confront negative thoughts or behaviors, they…Show more
Question: Is it allowed to vote in the following to help make the land of Israel frumer? They ask for affirmation on Zionism, that is NOT the Rebbe's shita. Attached is what one needs to agree to to.… Question: Is it allowed to vote in the following to help make the land of Israel frumer? They ask for affirmation on Zionism, that is NOT the Rebbe's shita. Attached is what one needs to agree to to. Here is the link to the Frum slate site: Eretzhakodesh.org Answer: There are several issues at play here and we will attempt to analyze them one by one. Endorsement of a secular organization: Though voting is somewhat of an endorsement of the organization at large, it appears to me that this is the same as voting for Knesset,…Show more
* This was written Rosh Chodesh Nissan 5780, at the height of the pandemic. Answer: Not appropriate to refrain. Sources: ראה משנ״ב תקעד בשעה״צ ח. כה״ח שם פג. פה.…
If the child is of age that he can eat a kezayis of grain within the amount of time that it takes an adult to eat a pras of grain (approx. 7 minutes), usually at the age of one… If the child is of age that he can eat a kezayis of grain within the amount of time that it takes an adult to eat a pras of grain (approx. 7 minutes), usually at the age of one year and older (but often even younger), one must keep a distance from his urine and excrements. The distance is 4 Amos from where the smell finishes, and they may not have it in their vision line when davening even if it's more than 4 Amos away. Nonetheless, it’s good and proper to daven in a clean place, even from…Show more
No. A Jewish child qualifies. מקורות טעמים: מסברא, נראה לכאו' דלא מהני גוי הן לפני החתונה והן לאחרי׳ ומכמה טעמים: הנה, המנהג שגם לפני החתונה לא יצאו החתן וכלה יחידי. וראה גם ביכורי יעקב תרסט, ד. ועוד. וטעם… No. A Jewish child qualifies. מקורות טעמים: מסברא, נראה לכאו' דלא מהני גוי הן לפני החתונה והן לאחרי׳ ומכמה טעמים: הנה, המנהג שגם לפני החתונה לא יצאו החתן וכלה יחידי. וראה גם ביכורי יעקב תרסט, ד. ועוד. וטעם המנהג כמבואר בכ״מ - וראה גם להלן - הוא למניעת נזק מכחות הרע והטומאה המנסים להזיק ולפגוע בחתן וכלה כדי לינוק ולקבל השפעה מצד הקדושה כו'. ועפ"ז מסתבר שענין השמירה נפעל דוקא ע"י יהודי שיש לו נפה"א מצד הקדושה. וסמוכין מע"ז כו, א ע"א ושו"ע יו״ד קנג, ה ושם קנד, א, ושם קנו, א, דחשידי אשפיכות דמים עיי"ש, ונהי דל"ש…Show more
It's hard to say there is something Halachicly forbidden about this. However, it definitely is not something I would recommend. The general atmosphere in theme parks are not in line with the chassidishe atmosphere, including the music, the shows,… It's hard to say there is something Halachicly forbidden about this. However, it definitely is not something I would recommend. The general atmosphere in theme parks are not in line with the chassidishe atmosphere, including the music, the shows, and the whole experience. In Disney parks there are many characters from movies, and the parked is "themed" around the movies. I would definitely consider this to be inappropriate and uneducational. (Some characters are also non Kosher animals, such as Mickey Mouse.) An additional but equally important point (particularly relevant for the summer time): theme parks is a place where…Show more
Answer: Ma'aser money can be used to pay for non-obligatory Mitzvos and writing a Sefer Torah to be used by a community is definitely a worthy cause. Nonetheless, since the primary purpose of Ma'aser is for the poor, it… Answer: Ma'aser money can be used to pay for non-obligatory Mitzvos and writing a Sefer Torah to be used by a community is definitely a worthy cause. Nonetheless, since the primary purpose of Ma'aser is for the poor, it isn't reasonable to use such a large amount of money for another mitzvah cause unless you're dealing with a shul which needs a Sefer Torah and can't afford it. Regardless, when using Ma'aser money, one does not fulfill the obligatory Mitzva of Writing a Sefer Torah and it would not count as a Zechus or leiluy nishmas. Sources: שקו״ט בפוסקים הן למ״ד שהוא לעניים. וגם למאי דקייל״ן…Show more
Many are lenient in this matter to trim with scissors the part of the mustache that interferes with eating. טעמים ומקורות: עיין באג"ק חי"ט ע' תכב במענה לשואל, שישאל אצל רבני אנ"ש היודעים הנהגה בפועל מחסידים הזקנים [כי… Many are lenient in this matter to trim with scissors the part of the mustache that interferes with eating. טעמים ומקורות: עיין באג"ק חי"ט ע' תכב במענה לשואל, שישאל אצל רבני אנ"ש היודעים הנהגה בפועל מחסידים הזקנים [כי יש צדדים לכאן ולכאן]. כידוע, ההוראה להקל בזה אם זה מפריע לאכילה. ומבוסס על דברי הרמב"ם הל' ע"ז פי"ב ה"ח המובאים בטור יו"ד סי' קפא שאם זה מפריע לאכילה מתירים לגלח קצתו עד שלא תתעכב האכילה. וכן נהג האריז״ל - ראה שעהמ״צ קדושים. (ובהתקשרות גל׳ רעו שזקני החסידים היו נמנעים. אבל ידוע שהרבה חסידים הקלו ואדרבה בכ״מ שאין להחמיר. וכמה…Show more
Question Continued: Am I right not to support her with this, which might lead to a colder relationship from her end? As it is, her Yiddishkeit is fragile, as reflected in her lack of tznius and I don't want… Question Continued: Am I right not to support her with this, which might lead to a colder relationship from her end? As it is, her Yiddishkeit is fragile, as reflected in her lack of tznius and I don't want to create any reasons on my end for her to weaken any further. I don't say anything to her when I hear or see her doing these shtick. But actively helping raises this question. Answer: If you won't be assisting her, she will most likely find a different source of assistance. Since you do not know for sure that…Show more
It is okay. ראה אג״ק חי״ב אגרת ג׳תתקכח: יישר כח על מאמרו נגד הפשרות, שזהו בקעה היותר מבהילה במדינה זו ובתקופה זו, ולא לבד שאין נוהגין כהוראת תורתנו במקרים כמו אלו שצריך להוסיף גדר, אלא שעוד מוסיפים פרצה… It is okay. ראה אג״ק חי״ב אגרת ג׳תתקכח: יישר כח על מאמרו נגד הפשרות, שזהו בקעה היותר מבהילה במדינה זו ובתקופה זו, ולא לבד שאין נוהגין כהוראת תורתנו במקרים כמו אלו שצריך להוסיף גדר, אלא שעוד מוסיפים פרצה על פרצה באמתלא שע"ז יצילו עכ"פ את המיעוט, אף שרואים במוחש ההיפך. ברם מה שכלל בזה גם הענין דחופה תחת כפת השמיםשנעשה פה ע"י חלל בגג הבית, צריך עיון, כי אין בזה פשרה אלא הענין במילואו. ולהעיר מאג״ק חי״ט אגרת ז׳תתי. #6870Show more
Have a Halachic Question?
Submit your question and receive an answer shortly.
Submit A Question
