People Just Asked
לכבוד הרה"ג הרב ברוין שליט"א, “Patterns Of Evidence” is a heavily advertised series of videos and books. In short, it is ran by Christians who go on missions to present evidence for the episodes in the תורה. This includes,… לכבוד הרה"ג הרב ברוין שליט"א, “Patterns Of Evidence” is a heavily advertised series of videos and books. In short, it is ran by Christians who go on missions to present evidence for the episodes in the תורה. This includes, evidence for יציאת מצרים, קריעת ים סוף and the sinking of the walls of יריחו amongst other episodes. Filmmakers scoured the areas that יציאת מצרים and קריעת ים סוף are believed to have taken place, and they dig in the ground, dive in to water, collect earth, search for footprints etc. to present evidence for the occurrences that are recorded…Show more
Rinsing and placing in the dishwasher is allowed. This is not considered preparing from Shabbos for the weekday as it cleans the kitchen in honor of Shabbos. However, you shouldn’t sort the dishes due to Borer. Sources: שו"ע אדה"ז סי' שכ"ג, ה. שו"ע אדה"ז שב, י. אג"מ…
Dear Rabbi, In Pirkei Avos (1:5) it says: ''Do not engage in excessive conversation with a woman. This is said even regarding one's own wife—how much more so regarding the wife of another''. I can't understand how it's forbidden to…Dear Rabbi, In Pirkei Avos (1:5) it says: ''Do not engage in excessive conversation with a woman. This is said even regarding one's own wife—how much more so regarding the wife of another''. I can't understand how it's forbidden to have a shmooze with a lady every now and then. For example; a few weeks back, I had women at my Shabbos table - people I have never met before, and we were shmoozing for around two hours! Never had I imagined that this is forbidden! And even more so, if there is one person in the whole world that…Show more
Question: I, as well as my chosson are devoted chassidim of the Lubavitcher Rebbe. There is a kallah teacher that I am very close to that is Chassidish (non-Lubavitch). She is willing to learn halachos al pi minhag chabad… Question: I, as well as my chosson are devoted chassidim of the Lubavitcher Rebbe. There is a kallah teacher that I am very close to that is Chassidish (non-Lubavitch). She is willing to learn halachos al pi minhag chabad for the sake of my classes. Is it OK or advisable to take classes with this teacher given my closeness and comfort with her and her willingness to learn our minhagim? Answer: Mazal tov, may you build a Binyan Adei Ad. There is no problem learning with that kalla teacher, on the contrary - there is a great…Show more
Under the current circumstances, they can stay and report, however they should make the greatest effort to be assigned to work which does not involve chilul Shabbos, and as you mentioned stay nearby and limit movement, etc. only… Under the current circumstances, they can stay and report, however they should make the greatest effort to be assigned to work which does not involve chilul Shabbos, and as you mentioned stay nearby and limit movement, etc. only acting in cases of pikuach nefesh. This is because without the proper protection and police presence, the protesters and rioters could lead to actual סכנת נפשות רח"ל. However if there is a specific daily pay for Shabbos work, they should donate it to tzedaka. PS. I find it hard to believe they wouldn't be able to get out of…Show more
It should be put back כלאחר יד - with back of hand or elbows. Sources: ראה סימן ש"ח סעיף ל"א ובמ"א שם שדוקא בבשר…
There is no mention in halacha about sleeping with one's feet facing the door, however, some people have a custom not to do so based on the fact that is the position a dead person faces in the chevra… There is no mention in halacha about sleeping with one's feet facing the door, however, some people have a custom not to do so based on the fact that is the position a dead person faces in the chevra kadisha. If this is not a family minhag, you don't have to be worried about it. Sources: מחמת שכך עושים בבר מינן (ראה תוד״ה בודק ב״ב…Show more
Regarding the halacha about not walking between two of the opposite gender: Q. What about if some of the people are sitting? -Like can a man walk down the aisle of a classroom where girls are sitting in the… Regarding the halacha about not walking between two of the opposite gender: Q. What about if some of the people are sitting? -Like can a man walk down the aisle of a classroom where girls are sitting in the desks? A. Same would apply, when possible. Q. How about if they're all sitting - like at a Shabbos table, is there an issue with a female sitting between two men? A. In practice you should be careful when able, see sources in the link below. Q. What about close family members, can they walk between each other?…Show more
Question: Do I need to make Birchos HaTorah before listening to a shiur? Does it make a difference whether it's a live shiur or a recording? Answer: When a person thinks the words of the Torah (as is… Question: Do I need to make Birchos HaTorah before listening to a shiur? Does it make a difference whether it's a live shiur or a recording? Answer: When a person thinks the words of the Torah (as is when listening to a shiur) he is not required to recite Birchos HaTorah. If however, the shiur is live (in person) it is suggested to say a Bracha, for one might have a question and end up discussing Torah verbally. שוע"ר סי' מז סעי' ב. Article: Are Torah MP3's Considered Learning Torah? The mitzvah of Talmud Torah consists…Show more
FREE TRANSLATION B”H, 10 Sivan 5780 Related to travel (for the foreseeable future, including Gimmel Tammuz): At this time, we do not regard air travel as safe for anyone except the lowest risk individuals on essential business. Susceptible… FREE TRANSLATION B”H, 10 Sivan 5780 Related to travel (for the foreseeable future, including Gimmel Tammuz): At this time, we do not regard air travel as safe for anyone except the lowest risk individuals on essential business. Susceptible individuals who travel outside the community are at risk of becoming ill in a setting where cases are still prevalent. Thus, when they return to Crown Heights, they should continue to separate themselves from vulnerable others, and monitor themselves closely, immediately reporting any suspicious symptoms. Particularly concerning are those travelling to Crown Heights, who may not have had the virus…Show more
Utensils that had Chalav Akum used in them need to be kashered before being used for Cholov Yisroel. One who uses strictly Cholov Yisroel should do the same after using Cholov "Stam". DE means that no kashering was done… Utensils that had Chalav Akum used in them need to be kashered before being used for Cholov Yisroel. One who uses strictly Cholov Yisroel should do the same after using Cholov "Stam". DE means that no kashering was done after being used previously for non Cholov Yisroel, and should not be eaten by someone who only eats Cholov Yisroel. Sources: רמ"א קטו, א. ש"ך סקי"ד, יז. ובנוגע לחלב הקאמפאניעס…Show more
Left. Sources: כבר האריכו בזה בכ״מ. וניחזי אנן - הנה הקדמת…
Regarding donating blood to a fellow Jew, it is clear that just as we must help a Jew monetarily, and we must even inconvenience ourselves to help, we must also go through the small discomfort involved in donating blood.… Regarding donating blood to a fellow Jew, it is clear that just as we must help a Jew monetarily, and we must even inconvenience ourselves to help, we must also go through the small discomfort involved in donating blood. Regarding donating blood to a non-Jew, most rabbinic authorities of the last generations have approved of this, and so is the common practice. Some of the explanations given: Since there is reciprocal benefit to the donor, either personally due to having donated, or to another Jew because there is enough blood to go around. Even if the Jews’ blood ends…Show more
Yes. Assuming that the dough is a Hamotzi dough and not a Mezonos dough. Being that that dough is there to impart flavor, and it’s satisfying to the pallet, it does not become nullified to the cheese. If the… Yes. Assuming that the dough is a Hamotzi dough and not a Mezonos dough. Being that that dough is there to impart flavor, and it’s satisfying to the pallet, it does not become nullified to the cheese. If the reason you are eating the calzone is for the cheese alone, and the bread around the cheese is merely to hold the cheese, and there is no pleasure from the flavor of dough, it would be Shehakol. ברכת הנהנין פ״ג ח. #8985Show more
Question: This year the 2nd night of Shavuos is on Shabbos. This means that al pi din, one can make kiddush early unlike a normal 2nd night. Although it's not the Chabad minhag, I may have to… Question: This year the 2nd night of Shavuos is on Shabbos. This means that al pi din, one can make kiddush early unlike a normal 2nd night. Although it's not the Chabad minhag, I may have to do it due to circumstances. My question is, would it make sense not to say shehechiyanu at kiddush, but wait until later after dark? The reason would be because in theory, if one forgot to say it on the first night, he can say it anytime the next day until sunset. This shows that it's still the first day.…Show more
No. Only in complete pesukim. Similar to here: https://asktherav.com/8623-saying-hashems-name-in-pirkei-avos #8918
מכתב קורונה עשרת הדברות FREE TRANSLATION BH, 2 Sivan, 5780 To all members of the community שיחיו In response to numerous inquiries: It is well known the Rebbe's directive that everyone, including small children, should attempt to be in shul…מכתב קורונה עשרת הדברות FREE TRANSLATION BH, 2 Sivan, 5780 To all members of the community שיחיו In response to numerous inquiries: It is well known the Rebbe's directive that everyone, including small children, should attempt to be in shul on the day of Matan Torah, at least during the reading of Aseres Hadibros. Accordingly, it is important to stress, due to the current situation: 1. The above must be in accordance with the health guidelines of professional expert doctors. Obviously, it’s forbidden to do so wherever there is any risk of danger חס ושלום, as this would fall under…Show more
This is after the Alter Rebbe's Shulchan Aruch and Mishna Brurah. I am a Lubavitcher. Just want expand my learning. Answer: For psak - Kaf Hachayim, unless it’s a case where he is following Kabalah and is… This is after the Alter Rebbe's Shulchan Aruch and Mishna Brurah. I am a Lubavitcher. Just want expand my learning. Answer: For psak - Kaf Hachayim, unless it’s a case where he is following Kabalah and is inconsistent with mainstream halacha. For analysis - Aruch Hashulchan. See also here: https://asktherav.com/if-there-is-a-disagreement-between-the-poskim-and-the-mekubalim-who-do-we-follow/ #8825Show more
Since only the Ba'al Koreh stands on his porch, does he say the Brochos for all Aliyos by himself, or can he say them on behalf of people standing on other porches (B'Shlichus)? If so, what's the preferred way?… Since only the Ba'al Koreh stands on his porch, does he say the Brochos for all Aliyos by himself, or can he say them on behalf of people standing on other porches (B'Shlichus)? If so, what's the preferred way? While AskTheRav and the Beis Din of Crown Heights will no longer be giving recommendations regarding what activities are encouraged or discouraged due to the current Covid-19 pandemic, we've been informed that professional and reliable medical advisors allow now others receiving Aliyos under very specific guidelines. The reply below assumes this is not the case or that the guidelines…Show more
No. But if one says - we need not protest. However, Magen Avos is said. נתבאר בארוכה בכינוס תורה אסרו חגה״ש תש"פ. #8752 (2)
Yes, if you designate a special place for the Sefer Torah first. Ideally, you should ensure to lain three times. If yes, what do I need to know about having a Sefer Torah in my home overnight? Be… Yes, if you designate a special place for the Sefer Torah first. Ideally, you should ensure to lain three times. If yes, what do I need to know about having a Sefer Torah in my home overnight? Be careful with its kedusha. Don't change pampers in that room. #8752 (1)Show more
One may "borrow" from their Maaser funds (but not from a Pushka). ראה שו”ע יו”ד סי’ רנז ס”ג שיכול להפריש צדקה וליתן על יד על יד. ועיין ט”ז סק”ג. ובדרך אמונה פ”ז מתנ”ע ס”ק ח כ”כ לגבי מעשר.… One may "borrow" from their Maaser funds (but not from a Pushka). ראה שו”ע יו”ד סי’ רנז ס”ג שיכול להפריש צדקה וליתן על יד על יד. ועיין ט”ז סק”ג. ובדרך אמונה פ”ז מתנ”ע ס”ק ח כ”כ לגבי מעשר. Regarding buying with Maaser money, please see here: https://asktherav.com/using-maaser-for-seforim/ #8374Show more
Question: My 4 year old daughter usually goes to sleep around 7pm. It is not an issue to light the candles earlier for shabbos after plag. We don't light candles early for the Shavuos, right? I still can see… Question: My 4 year old daughter usually goes to sleep around 7pm. It is not an issue to light the candles earlier for shabbos after plag. We don't light candles early for the Shavuos, right? I still can see her stretch and stay up till around 8- for the first night. What is the solution for the second night of Yom Tov when the lighting will be around 9pm in NY? Answer: Our custom is to light early for Yom Tov, including Shavuos, as we do for Shabbos. This year (5780) the second day is Shabbos so we…Show more
If the people in the cars can see each other (or at least the chazzan can) they can be combined as 10 people for a minyan, provided no public thoroughfare separates between them. The car window is must remain… If the people in the cars can see each other (or at least the chazzan can) they can be combined as 10 people for a minyan, provided no public thoroughfare separates between them. The car window is must remain open, so there is no actual mechitzah between them. שוע"ר סי' נה סעי' טז ובמ"ב שם ס"ק נב וכה"ח שם ס"ק עו (בנוגע לפתיחת החלון) וראה פסקי תשובות שם סעי' כו. #8604Show more
Question: I have a question about cooking a roast in a bag in the crockpot. I fill the pot with water and potatoes I put the meat in a bag with spices and tie it shut and put it… Question: I have a question about cooking a roast in a bag in the crockpot. I fill the pot with water and potatoes I put the meat in a bag with spices and tie it shut and put it on top of the potatoes in the water. I would like to put this up on Friday to eat Shabbos day. Is this allowed? Answer: The food should either be half cooked before Shabbos, or there should be at least 1 piece of meat that's raw. For more information see here: https://asktherav.com/article-478-using-a-crock-pot-on-shabbos/ Using a bag in a crockpot can…Show more
Have a Halachic Question?
Submit your question and receive an answer shortly.
Submit A Question
